September 24, 2012

Not truth and knowledge

I think it is interesting that Locke pints out the complexity of our language and the words we use more in a moral sense up into 34 sections. Maybe this is me trying to connect my other rhetoric class and the background "enlightenment" piece, but isn't that the whole point of rhetoric. That although words have a definitional meaning but when we really think about a tree me might not all see the same tree. I might see a black and white tree, you might see a cartoon tree and your friend might see a oil paint version of the tree. Maybe I am not understanding why he is trying to isolate rhetoric and the definitions we use as a society down into a perfect line.

September 23, 2012

ecoPorn... is it really that bad??

Ecoporn is a term I had was not familiar with before Bart’s fascinating article on it. Everything he said he made it very easy for us as readers to connect with. The examples of how Ecoporn is used to alter our perception of things and exploit females and sexuality really raised some concerns for people in the class. Oddly enough I think I may have a different take on this Ecoprn than the class. Of course I do not like the manipulation and basically scheming Ecoporn is affiliated with, but if you think about it what actual harm is it causing? We act as if we are not hit over the head with misleading; devious, and sometimes flat out lies every single day probably every hour. That is all we see in promotions, campaigns, and commercials. This is why I do not understand why people are so offened by Ecoporn. The fact is the "porn" aspect of ecoporn is what grabs our attention. It is what may save you from eating that little piggy or saving a turtle just by disposing of your trash correctly.

Civil Miscommunication v. Philosophical Miscommunication

I understand and appreciate the claims Locke makes about signification, but I think he doesn't completely portray the issue -- he confines the imperfection of words almost entirely to the philosophical use of words.
"It is true, as to civil and common conversation, the general names of substances, regulated in their ordinary signification by some obvious qualities... do well enough to design the things men would be understood to speak of... But in philosophical inquiries and debates, where general truths are to be established, and consequences drawn from positions laid down, there the precise signification of the names of substances will be found not only not to be well established, but also very hard to be so." (821-822)

Locke's Contradiction: His Writing Style vs His Message

What I found ironic about Locke's philosophy on words and meanings was the contradiction between his writing style and the message he conveyed. He calls for a "plain" style without excessive ornamentation or complexity. However, I would not consider the writing style of this work "plain". He says the end of language is to be understood, yet I had a difficult time understanding the complex ways he elaborates on his ideas about language. I would not say that I did not grasp the main concepts Locke discusses, but I would say this understanding could have come more quickly and with more ease had he applied the concepts he spoke of to his own writing. I feel like he says the same thing, in more or less words, several times throughout the essay. I also found myself confused with some of his word choice, which seems to vary when standing for the same idea, something I believe Locke himself would consider a poor choice for the sake of others' understanding.

Questioning Meaning


Locke is a true enlightenment thinker because he challenged the signification of words by discussing their imperfections. He “reconsidered the source and status of knowledge" (Bizzell/Herzberg 791) by “paying particular attention to the psychological processes of communication" (Bizzell/Herzberg 791) and that is how he came to the idea that “the imperfection of words is t doubtfulness or ambiguity of their signification, which is caused by the sort of ideas they stand for" (Locke 817). Words that are imperfect, question the knowledge people have of them and if they are true. Words are generated through knowledge because "the idea which each stands for must be learned and retained" (Locke 818) and if knowledge is something learned then this statement is true.

Feeling Enlightened?: Why Emotion is Essential

The reading I chose was this look into the background of rhetoric during the Enlightenment. Many different ideas were forged during the enlightenment, whether they were completely new ways of thinking, or modifications of old ideas. It's no surprise that, when given the change, rhetoric would be looked at and possibly change for the better.

The particular ideas that came to mind were the "plain" styles that people like Bacon and Descartes wanted more emphasized. By the time I had read and understood the ideas behind such a take for progression I thought it to be a good idea that is very unlikely to work.

My prior studies in philosophy have always been helped by the fact that my first professor didn't just have a doctorate in philosophy. He had one in neuroscience as well. He often talked about how the brain developed and how long it takes to get that frontal lobe going with the "reasoning" aspect of ourselves. The problem with this "plain" take on everything is the fact that our brains developed in a way that the flat-out facts won't cut it for a motivation. As humans, it seems the best we can do is set our minds on something, steer in the direction with reason, and use emotion as a driving force. When we employ rhetoric, we harness the emotions of others towards a greater good assuming we use our reasoning. Same goes for them as a rebuttal. They'll assess the situation using reasoning and push forward with emotion. We do greater things that way. The flat out facts won't always get the job done.

Just sounds or communicated ideas?

Locke's explanation of language is not very clear to me. I feel like he tries to really explain all of the issues with language in very in depth ways, but then talks about how more simple ideas are better for easier communication between humans. This essay to me was not a simple idea at all, and I found it hard to follow. One part that stood out to me was under number 9 when he says that sounds are learned first and then the meanings come later. this interested me because I remember I have many nieces and nephews that I watched learn how to talk and then in turn learn the meaning. At first, they would try and mimic what we were saying and only paying attention to the sounds they were hearing. they were not even yet old enough to hold a conversation. Later, I watched them try and put meanings to all of these sounds that they were learning. this was fascinating to me, but I never looked that closely into it until after reading this essay.

Locke & Understanding

Locke's essay on understanding wasn't very well understood. I feel like Locke analyzed too many parts of language and attempted to run too in depth into language as a tool or part of everyday communication. For example, as he comments on "simple ideas." Locke states that "....simple ideas are, of all others, the least liable to mistakes, and that for these reasons: First, Because the ideas they stand for, being each but one single perception, are much easier got, and more clearly retained, than the more complex ones, and therefore are not liable to the uncertainty which usually attends those compounded ones of substances and mixed modes, in which the precise number of simple ideas that make them up are not easily agreed, so readily kept in mind" (823). I think that it is evident to our community today that simple seems to be the key. Simple ideas allow for communication between all walks of life and educational experience easier.

Where the "agent" can finally appear

In conjunction with the idea of "author death," and the removal of his being from the process of "writing," the idea of Agent also quickly fades away. If the author is no longer thought to bear the unique power of imposing ultimate meaning on the text, or at the very least, thought to be the fountain from which the text springs forth, then his central position as the Agent of text, or language, has disappeared; perhaps even realized as never existing.

So where can Agent appear? For Foucault, it rested in the author's transition to the sociallly based, "Author-function," and Barthes, although not explicit, the Agent seemed to rest in language itself. However, what seems to be problematic in the location of the contemporary Agent, lies not in its new position, but in the failure of its conception as something that could be pluralistic.

The "truth" is in your head

Language as a tool for communication. Locke mentions on page 818, "Without ideas, men fill one another's heads with noise and sounds; but convey not thereby their thoughts..." In relation to the notion of truth and finding it, does this mean that every person must have a relative experience of whatever it is that the speaker is talking about in order to know exactly what it is that they are talking about?

Language as a tool for attaining the truth. If language and rhetoric go hand in hand, how can we get the truth from these techniques? I think first we need to have a clear definition or at least an ideal concept of truth. According to Locke, what is the truth that we are trying to discover through rhetoric and is it really the truth? Can we ever fully attain that truth that we seek through rhetoric or language?

understanding agency

While writing our papers on the agency paradox I have finally come to a better understanding of what agency is now compared to how we first described it in the beginning as one practical definition that agency is the condition or state of being that includes power.  Thanks to both of Campbell’s essays and Barton’s essay I finally understand that agency cannot be just one thing because it changes every time do to what situation arises sometimes changing in one situation to fit the needs of everything.  Like how Campbell describes agency as “1) communal and participatory, hence, both constituted and constrained by externals that are material and symbolic; 2) is ‘invented’ by authors who are points of articulation; 3) emerges in artistry or craft; 4) is effected through form; and 5) is perverse, that is, inherently, protean, ambiguous, open to reversal.” (Campbell, 2) Recognizing now that agency can be all of these different things I can better understand what the agency is in Barton’s essay, the ads themselves, and Campbell’s feminist essay the agency for those women that wanted equality is perhaps their feminist style, a craft learning skill.

September 22, 2012

Locke And the Weakness of Language

Having studied Locke's epistemological writing (as well as his political and ethical philosophies which for the sake of this discussion should be considered separate) in Philosophy of Language, I feel that Locke exposes a very important consideration for students of rhetoric, that language is the factor which introduces the highest degree of ambiguity to discourse and not competing theories of knowledge. Though I do think Locke utilizes strange lines of reasoning at times, I feel that he is entirely correct to assert that knowledge is non-relativistic, unambiguous, and clear whereas language, our tool of communication is steeped in arbitrariness and convention to the point where it obscures our own impressions of awareness, preventing them from being understood by others. Though the broadness of common language may make it sufficient  for civil use (Locke says it doesn't, I'm really not certain whether or not that is the case yet), its lack of precision becomes particularly apparent in philosophical discourse. Simply think about how hard it is to establish non-problematic definitions of the most foundational concepts for this class such as "agency," "audience," or "work." Is it the case that we only have a redundant or tautological understanding of these concepts? Or is it instead the case that language fails us because every word has different connotations to every individual and their lived experience?

September 18, 2012

Ecopornography - Commodity Fetishism


Bart Welling’s ”Ecoporn” exposes the commoditization of nature in the media. The following passage is representative of the main idea of the piece.

“Ecopornography is a type of contemporary visual discourse made up of highly idealized, anthropomorphized views of landscapes and nonhuman animals. While these images often are composed or manipulated to stress their subject’s innate similarities to the human body and to human social and power structures (such as the nuclear family, patriarchy, and the nation state), the images work to conceal both the material circumstances of their creation by humans and whatever impact humans may have had on the landforms and animals they depict”

September 17, 2012

Ecoporn

  I found Welling’s definition of the term “Ecoporn” to be quite effective and convincing.  I had no experience with the term before this reading, and when he began stating his argument I had no idea how he was going to create connections / draw parallels with aspects of feminism. However, Welling makes an excellent argument.  He creates an image for us of the typical viewer/consumer of visual images of nature (whether they be an awareness ad, documentary, or just a shot of nature in all of it’s splendor) as an all-powerful voyeuristic male.  He believes that this viewer equates his seemingly omnipotent vision with an equal knowledge of the subject (nature) which he can exploit as he chooses.  Nature, whether it is landscape or nonhuman animals, is representative of the victim, the exploitable, female.  From the ecopornograhy lens, parallels between this objectification of nature and that of women in pornography are clearly evident.  As an example Welling points out the similarities of women at a peep show and animals at a zoo, both are seen as spectacles, they are being objectified. 


Confusion with Profusion Meanings in Agency


         I think the problem I have with most classes dealing with rhetoric is that they never receive one definite answer and that is exactly what Campbell is addressing in Agency: Promiscuous and Protean. In class we discussed that agency was “the condition or state of being that includes power, or the ability to do something.” When I translate that I take it as the ability to do something with power. Campbell suggests this power is done by a group that shares the same ideas, it is “invented”, it emerges and is done only through one’s own free will. This idea that agency is modern is troubling me because I feel that agency has been around as long as mankind. It may seem modern because it is just recently being addressed, but even in the time during Christ there were groups that orchestrated things only because they had the power too. The Jews had enough power to crucify him and that agency is not modern.

Ecoporn

When I first started reading Welling's piece on Ecoporn, it took me a while until I could full grasp what he was talking about (and I'm still not sure if I do). From what I could gather, Welling defines ecoporn as a type of visual discourse that transforms nature and nonhuman animals into highly idealized and sexual representations. While I can see where he is coming from, I think his examples of The Discovery Channel and The Crocodile Hunter as exploiting animals in a sexual way is sort of far fetched. I do however agree with the notion that "women are naturalized and animalized." Especially in today's society, women are used all over advertising to sell products and gain attention from the intended audience. I'm also not sure if I agree with his statement, "along with standard pornography, [ecoporn] has the capacity to empower as well as to degrade." The way I see it, pornography only degrades, the person being exploited and the viewer him/herself.

Exposing Nature: XXX

Although Bart H. Welling did not coin the term 'ecoporn' his text, Ecoporn, was my first encounter with such a topic. In fact the first man to employ the term was Jerry Mander in his 1972 work, Ecopornography. To Mander, the word can be defined similarly to the OED definition of 'green wash'- disinformation disseminated by an organization, etc., so as to present an environmentally responsible public image (Welling 54). Some great examples of this have happened recently since the BP oil spill across the Gulf. BP has generated commercials showing flourishing lands unaffected by the colossal oil spill; the company is attempting to trick the public into thinking that thanks to BP the Gulf area is back to its clean environmentally thriving self, pre-spill. Of course these images are deceiving and have been furthered labeled as 'ecoporn' since they are  counterproductive and instead of educating the public about ecostemic abuses, they anesthetize viewers by constructing an illusion of pure, safe, nature (55).

Sojourner Truth's Fictionalized Voice

As a white abolitionist, Gage represented Truth in the voice that she felt was appropriate for the message despite Truth being from the Netherlands she gives Truth the dialect of a black southern slave. By giving Truth a heavy black southern accent she gives her a fictionalized voice.

This is Gage’s attempt to construct audience, by making Truth more of a “figure” for the southern black women her was to appease to that specific audience and to empathizers of that group. “That written text represents Truth’s speech in the white abolitionist’s imagined idiolect of The Slave, the supposedly archetypical black plantation slave of the South” (Logan 20) I personally battle with how to take in Gage’s efforts. Although I understand that making Truth this figure of the strong black southern woman could help to further women’s rights and abolition, the stereotypical framing of Truth is borderline offensive no matter the intentions. It suggests that without that dialect her argument would not be relatable to black southern women and that the empathizers of this group would not be able to receive the message without this false figure.
 

Establishing "Normalcy" and the United Way in the 1950's

I thought the article Textual Practices of Erasure was interesting in the sense that the general argument of the essay was that it "contextualizes front-stage textual practices in terms of the central contradictions of the American 1950s: Underlying the celebration of American goodness expressed in charity was profound uneasiness about the presence of disabled others who were different from the American mainstream, unease that is allayed by erasure." The United Way used sympathy of people who were disabled to get funding in a world that was seen upbeat and almost perfect. People with disabilities were typically seen as less human, and although these ads did bring that division to mind, I do think it did the job in raising awareness and not ignoring the elephant in the room of someone with disabilities, so to speak. I can see where it can cause issues with exploiting people and using children to generate sympathy from an audience, but at the same time, I think it is the only way to get the job done.

Ecoporn's Purpose

The general purpose of the term "Ecoporn", is to evade the possibility of  turning our worlds natural attributes into commodities. By definition a commodity is any economic fixture that can be produced to satisfy a need or want. What I have come to realize though is that our worlds natural aspects have always been a commodity. Even the early protestant values from the first European settlers in America speak to this when they claimed to seek a "city upon a hill". The only difference, is that today we have millions of people with access to the worlds natural resources and with the ability of destruction and abuse. Back then we were cutting down trees one by one just to build log cabins (no real impact).

Ecoporn, A New Perspective

I found the "Ecoporn" article to be very interesting. Last semester I took "Rhetorical Criticism", and we analyzed slasher films and how they sexualized, and de-sexualized, the female heroines. I never would have thought to apply a similar analysis to pictures of nature.

While I'm not sure if Welling's argument is totally sound, I understand the main points. Untouched landscapes with "female" characteristics can be appealing to the unconscious concept of a "virgin female body". I'm not sure I understood what Welling's was claiming was so wrong about this similarity, other than women would probably be offended that they are being portrayed as animals. A problem I found, and I saw that someone discussed this below, is that Welling really only talked about how ecoporn depicted women sexually. When he brought up the image of the Florida Panther, which I can see vividly as it was my highschool mascot, big, buff and black, with its beating yellow eyes, if I had to guess what gender it was trying to sexualize, I would definitely say male. While landscapes may look more "female", it should also be considered that some of these rolling hills and venus fly traps really do look like female anatomy parts. I could also probably find many phallic symbols in ecoporn if I looked for them, which I feel like Welling didn't.

Erasure Eraser.

Ellen L. Barton's article "Textual Practices of Erasure: Representations of Disability and the Founding of the United Way" has a very noble cause: unmask and denounce rhetoric that negatively alters our perceptions of the disabled. Barton says this rhetoric uses pity and fear to "evoke readers' feelings of good fortune, their suppressed fears of vulnerability, and their pride in American values and institutions" (195). Although campaigns operating this way (for example the United Way's) are most often  successful, Barton cautions that it "regularly diminishes the experience of the people with disabilities and ultimately diminishes the understanding of disability by society at large" (195).
I absolutely agree with Barton in this respect; she provides a variety of campaign posters/articles that exaggerate the negative condition of the handicapped in order to amplify some effect on the reader.

Feminine rhetoric and the evolution of the epistime

The influence of  gender roles has been an influential componet of contemporary society virtually since the beginning of human civilization. The gender roles and rules which dictate their function have been a fundamental aspect in the determation of available opportunities for men and women, as they have been seen throughout history to be applied with the rigid inflexability of law. The role of gender is not inherent, however, and has no form of biological composition or any other form of absolute truth by which to justify it's structure. Therefore, the development and evolution of feminist rhetorical practices can be viewed as a revolutionary element which was fundamental to the evolution of the epistime to encourage a greater sense of equality between men and women.

Rhetorical relation and Campbell's Theory

The most interesting articles of the semester so far, at least to me, have been the Campbell and Heilbrun pieces. The idea that Campbell presents, the notion that a women's  siterature or a women's agency, can stem from an already established rhetorical genre or agency is much more plausible than an entire entire women's rhetorical movement that comes from nothing. I could not help but link this "constrained agency" to African-American literature. African-Americans ccreated a literature, an agency, from the confinement and constrain of an oppressive context and used that context to blossum. If a heirarchy is in place and a dominant ideolgy is in poace that is oppresive to the groups that are not in power, those groups that are not in power can create their own ways of gaining power frpm qithin their constraints. I believe this is why Campbell referenced "the Pheonix."

ECOPRON and the passion for perceiving

This isn't the first time I've compared particular art forms with something as primeval as sexual desires. Hell, last semester I had to give a presentation on The Passion of Perceiving by Christian Metz. It was essentially about how watching cinema is a primeval desire. Some examples listed were films like Psycho or Rear Window which is all about watching people, especially in a sexual way.

It appeals to the part of the brain that has been with us the longest: the reptilian system. It's always considered our deepest darkest desires because it's literally the deepest part of the brain. The arts, like photographs and film and everything in between seek to appeal to things that are human. Ecoporn is no different. Sexuality is a completely human thing to experience and when exposed with nature, it allows us to realize just how human the world, as a whole, is, not just the urban or rural areas of human habituation.