I think a majority of our theorists have touched on this point: it is difficult for us to understand each other.
Barthes wrote about the difficulties of understanding a text when its author is not there to explain. Focault wrote about the perceptions of an author which cloud our judgment of a text. Ong wrote about a fictionalized relationship where understanding is a constructed hope. Campbell, Heilbrun, Welling, Barton cried out for the voices lost beneath a text.
Together they present an image of a person who desperately seeks to be understood, and who seeks to understand their own nature through personal dialogue. As Locke puts it, "men fill one another's heads with noise and sound, but convey not thereby their thoughts (818)." We can speak, but our intepretations of each other are biased by our experiences. Locke's philosophy of rhetoric attempts to find a solution to this problem, but it may be one that cannot be solved.
September 24, 2012
The significance of Words
Words do not serve well when trying to be
understood. For the listener can find significance in a word differently than
the speaker, creating imperfect communication. If you are confused about how
this works all you have to do is look back at the first part of Locke’s essay
where he is talking about words as recording. Our ability to take a single word
and give it significance so that we remember an something else or an entire
idea/theory shows how, depending on the way in which one thinks, they may attach
a completely different idea to a word than another person would while in
discourse. Most of the time we are able to understand one another when we use a
certain word, commercials depend on certain phrases or words to communicate for
them, and because we see/hear these ideas so much we are able to recognize the
significance of that word in a particular context and can even purposefully
take it out of that context. Yet at other times this becomes more difficult. Locke
calls these more difficult words imperfect for many reasons, one of them being
the complexity of the word.
rhetoric is an art...right?
I'll admit: sometimes, for the sake of increasing word count or making myself seem like I know what I'm actually talking about, I've use a painstaking amount of words to convey one particular idea. I've even confused myself before because of how many times I try to go around a subject matter before I actually try and attack it and even then, it's a thinly veiled attempt to just make myself seem smarter. So, while I'd hate to agree with Locke on this one, I have to - in some respects.
Using ornate language can be a good thing - if I'm reading a story that has kind of a dull or ridiculously common plot, I tend to enjoy it more when it has beautiful language and paints pictures for me because it's their command of language that sets them apart from other people's works. I'd much rather read a story that can capture me through their figurative language than one that captures me solely because I can predict the ending because I've read it a million times.
Using ornate language can be a good thing - if I'm reading a story that has kind of a dull or ridiculously common plot, I tend to enjoy it more when it has beautiful language and paints pictures for me because it's their command of language that sets them apart from other people's works. I'd much rather read a story that can capture me through their figurative language than one that captures me solely because I can predict the ending because I've read it a million times.
Locke's Language Stance
I will admit, I had to read through Locke's An Essay Concerning Human Understanding a few times before I could fully grasp what he was saying about the function of language and thought, and how they work with each other to form abstract ideas. He is almost self-fulfilling with his definition of language being imperfect, where words can mean different things and it is up to the understanding of the person on the other side of communication to fully grasp what is being communicated by what words are available. I have often wondered about the formulation of words, and how "tree" can mean one thing to us, but nothing to someone else who has another word for it-- that language is developed to attach an idea to things that exist. However, I never really thought about the complexity of words that are not attached to material things, like in his example, glory and gratitude (819). It is a collective idea that is expressed in our language one way, but different in another way. As people start learning these "moral words," their meanings assessed to them are what they experience the word to be, rather than what it is materially (like a tree). It stood out to me that he addresses language as imperfect and changing; a rather new standpoint in 17th century rhetoric, as pointed out in Bizzell/Herzberg's piece on the Enlightenment. Overall, the reformation of language to simplicity and analytical stance on the core meaning of words proved to be a pivotal point in the development of modern language, which can clearly be attributed to Locke and other notable rhetoricians.
The "Truth" of Language
The main point that I took away from Locke's essay was this: We are all different, and we use language in different ways than others around us. Language has specific roles that it plays, and the more complex the role, the more likely we are to encounter a misunderstanding in meaning. Locke says of language, "It is easy to perceive what imperfection there is in language, and how the very nature of words makes it almost unavoidable for many of them to be doubtful and uncertain in their significations" (817).
Mr. John Locke
Like many of the rhetoricians we've covered in this course already, Locke looked at a specific subject (his subject being words) and tried to explain its importance in the world of rhetoric. In my opinion, I find Locke's views of words to be almost too simple because he tries to break down the usage of them into two categories, when using words is often times much more complex than that. The two categories that he explains for using words are to record our own thoughts and to communicate our thoughts to others. When you take a look at history, when different presidents have given speeches, the words they choose to influence people and to motivate them are very powerful, and Locke seems to think that words don't have much meaning.
Agent for Ambiguity
In many of my EWM classes, we have
started the semester’s discussion debating the definition of a certain word;
whether it be rhetoric, classical, agent/cy, or meaning. Throughout these
classroom debates many valid and conflicting ideas get thrown around, leaving
the class flustered and reaching the conclusions that a word can “mean”
anything because we are the ones that give it meaning. As insightful to meaning
as that is, it frustrates me that this is always the conclusion the class comes
to. As humans we have been proven wrong so many times, the earth being flat,
Pluto existing…. Yet we still take every discovery we make as truth and are
uncomfortable with ambiguity.
Locke's Word Ambiguity
What
I found interesting about Locke's discussion has been a common theme in
this class: Interpretation of something that we are used to in every
day life that
can often be overlooked. With Foucault, it was the analysis of the
author and what defines them-- something that we may not think about day
to day. In the instance of Locke, it was the discussion of words and
what exactly they can do: the foundation of discourse.
Locke insists that there are exactly two ways that words can be used: to
record your own thoughts, and to communicate your thoughts to other
people. He also says, however, that words are only arbitrary ideas,
which seems contradicting to me. If words are subjective,
then how are we supposed to covey our ideas or thoughts to other people?
Bizzell/Herzberg's background on Locke even says that he thinks words
are ambiguous and that they only refer to ideas. Locke also insists that
words are the source of our ideas, which
also confused me because I thought he said that words can only
communicate or record ideas. I may be reading into this a little too
literally, but I find much of Locke's discussion to be contradicting.
What's the Big Idea, Locke?
Locke's view on language and how it needs to be purified is one thing. But wanting a plain style of text, who would ever want that? As writers we create works that would appeal to an audiance. Plain text is so boring, in my opinion. But I get what he is saying in a way, to make text a universal symbol, something that everyone can understand. He says that words represent ideas, not things. I agree with this, but sometimes in areas such as poetry and other descriptive senses words can represent things symbolically. I agree with everyone when they sy Locke's style of writing is contradicting to his message. However, his message gives us a different view point on what text can be. Also, if it was as plain as he proposes it should be, I would have a lot more difficulty reading through it.
If words weren't misinterpreted, why would we communicate?
After a few pages on Locke I couldn’t help but ask myself
what he means by complex ideas not being universal?
Locke clearly stated the line before that complex ideas were
in fact formed by “connections among simple ideas.” If that is in fact true why
aren’t complex ideas universal?
Anyone in fact could create a complex idea, but what Locke misses
is the context he places his belief of a complex idea. There must something
that signifies an idea is complex, when in reality joining simple ideas is
rather (simple) and could be everything that occurs naturally. To Locke’s
definition, in reality the connections of simple activities could be considered
complex.
Rhetoric: Choosing Words to Represent Ideas
John Locke separates words into two distinct groups: "First, One for the recording of our own thoughts. Secondly, The other for the communicating of our thoughts to others" (Locke, Pg 817). The power of word choice instantly shows the separation between the core message of any rhetorical speech and the words chosen to represent this meaning. The ambiguity and meaninglessness of the words we use to shape these ideas is emphasized by Locke, "For since sounds are voluntary and indifferent signs of any ideas, a man may use what words he pleases to signify his own ideas to himself" (Pg 817). Locke shows how unimportant words are in the shaping of our theories, as he literally strips all words of all meaning. At the same time, this shows how important words are in the actual act of getting out our ideas and representing them. In making this distinction, I think he properly defends rhetoric by showing how utterly dependent it is on the user. For if words are simply chosen to represent the ideas that are formulated, how can the words be blamed? At the same time, it shows how easily rhetoric can be distorted often purposefully by the user and other times a result of their lack of understanding of those words.
The fallacy of wordplay
It has long been recognized that words retain an influence which prevades their actual meaning and outlast their usage, but there is very little regard to the reasons for which words are endowed with such value, or from where this value is derived. John Locke seeks to tackle this discrepancy head on in his philosophically framed empirical observations on the influence and effectiveness of words, and largely language in general, in providing the medium of communication between different people. Lock proposes that words in themselves are an imperfect means for communication between people, particularly those of whom have established drastically different or opposing structures through which reality is perceived, due to the uncertain and often subjective nature of the value of the words themselves.
Agency in Ecoporn and United Way
In both the Ecoporn and United Way articles, there was a idea that the mentioned ads/practices lead to the loss of agency for the represented group. Even though most of the examples were ads, there were still writers behind them, so I wondered how author function could fit into this idea of agency in the articles. In the United Way ads, the tone of the text encourages pity and guilt towards the disabled, but strives to make the reader feel good about them self. When the article mentioned how the tone of the ads differed throughout the years, i think that was also a good example of author function. Depending on the values of the decade, the ads othered the disabled base on different criteria. So, the authors of those had to be aware of what the common values were. They knew what was currently viewed as the "normal America." This shows that the ads existed alongside the common culture. In fact, since advertising has always tried to stay current with what the majority of people like and want, looking at older ads can give a lot of information about how writers attempted to appeal to their readers. I think a part of author function is being aware of your audience. In both Ecoporn and United Way, we see authors/text that are very aware of their audience, and so they were effective.
Enlightenment
Bizzell and Herzberg said, the scientific and philosophical
revolutions of the seventeenth century affected rhetoric in a number of ways.
First starting off with the effect of ‘indirect.’ Which resulted in a change
with the conception of logic, which is known to be a branch of knowledge
dealing with rhetoric. However, as experimental science and inductive reasoning
replaced deductive logic as “the standard of inquiry…” Critics of this century
believed that literature was purposeful and intended to please and instruct the
reader, which I believe to its entirety to this day. When I think of how
literature is purposeful, the art of persuasion easily comes to mind. The art
of persuasion ran straight along with the art of poetry. How the art of
persuasion deals with the new theories of psychology where rhetoricians
confirmed the idea that reasoning and imagination were the key mental
faculties, especially in persuasion.
A Method to a Madness
Our blogspot is a clear demostration of Locke's
ideas about words and the use of
language. An Essay Concerning Human Understanding sounds like
a title for a large philosophical journal; almost parallel to the question,
"what is the meaning of life?" However, by the first page I noticed
this essay connects directly to our lives in class. This blog is a prime
example of the double use of words the Locke describes in the beginning of the
chapter.
John Locke: A Way With Words
In Book III of From An Essay of Human Understanding John Locke goes into the signification of words and their subjective meanings. As a writer, words tend to become ambiguous in meaning, and in use. The exact purpose of words is just as vague as the meaning itself. I agree with Locke's definition on the function of words. They are meant to transcript thoughts and also to communicate those thoughts. Of course this will vary by culture and region on exactly which words are used to record what, in a general sense this may be the most commonly accepted function of words. Words are the symbols of yesteryear and probably the extinct version of recordings in the distant future. Once Locke goes into the communication of words thats when things start to complicate. The same words we used to write our ideas are the same ones we used to relay and communicate these ideas. Communicating ordinary day to day things and expressions is more of the "civil" function Locke mentions. The problem is the philosophical function. This one is a puppet of opinion and opinion is married to interpretation. Interpretation goes back to the primary functions of rhetoric as the interoperation is manipulated by the means of persuasion. So the more a word is used to persuade the more into the question its true meaning becomes.
Get These Words on a Locke Down
John
Locke had ideas that bordered Plato’s ideas of the nominal world and that most
people were indeed blind to this “real” world. There were some minute
differences in the ideas, such as believing in scientific experimentation to
come to the truths of the world where as Plato believed a person could get
there by simply talking to somebody who knew the truths. In this way I think
that Locke was able to surpass the Sophists, Plato, and Aristotle’s thought
processes by including the practices of actual sciences, which makes a lot of
sense when a person is trying to find and teach facts to people. The three philosophical
realms of thought mentioned in the prior sentenced were all focused on coming
to truth and understanding and helping people understand the world around them.
They came to these truths, however, by simply speaking about the subjects using
their oratory skills. Locke believed that method of teaching was basically
garbage and by using Bacon’s scientific method, he learned things from
experimentation and helped others learn said things by showing them his methods.
Understanding Locke: is it possible?
As a warning I should probably tell you that this journal is slightly all over the place. We had talked about Locke in my Rhetoric class over the summer but it was only for a day, a couple hours really, and he was mixed in with Bacon and Hume. So, when I began reading his text "Essay of Human Understanding" I was a little confused. The wording was harder for me to decipher than some of the other works we have read so I'm sort of drawing on the knowledge I learned over the summer to try to fill in the gaps.
Further expanding Locke
Ambiguity is not something to be feared. Albeit a challenge to the symbol making animals we, as humans, are and our constant need to determine what something is, or isn't, it is by far our most difficult challenge (Burke, Definition of Man). This is no major issue to me, the ambiguity of words as possibly inaccurate signs of even more ambiguous ideas that are signs of world phenomena. I personally take this, and I believe Locke did as well, as a great challenge that we as humans should take on together. It is by our debate, discourse, agreement, dispute, and refutation that our words have meaning at all. Perhaps they are at times ambiguous, and at other times inaccurate, but they are most vital asset in making sense of our world and all its common, or not so common, occurrences.
What John Locke Learned on the Island
John Locke can talk for a long, long time and use many words to discuss how words inherently have no meaning, and they are extremely unreliable. You now, he has a point. I feel like I must not be alone in saying that I’ve wondered how certain words get associated with certain things so definitively throughout the entire geography of a language. It really is an amazing thing, but I had never quite realized what a fickle thing it is at the same time.
The word “hatch,” for example. What does that word mean? In my own life and experience, I would describe a hatch as a large door with an air lock. John Locke might say it is a bunker buried in the ground. The word to him becomes associated with much more than what my understanding of it is.
The word “hatch,” for example. What does that word mean? In my own life and experience, I would describe a hatch as a large door with an air lock. John Locke might say it is a bunker buried in the ground. The word to him becomes associated with much more than what my understanding of it is.
Using rhetoric everyday
Bizzell
& Herzberg’s background on the enlightenment of rhetoric is an interesting
overview and history of the term and how the term itself has evolved throughout
the centuries. Whether the term is
being associated with poetry, scientific discussion, history or even literary
criticism, rhetoric has evolved and progressed the way speech and thought is
delivered. Historically speaking, rhetoric is linked with the use of language
when someone is trying to hide the truth from you. It’s associated with shady car
salesmen and corrupt politicians. This kind of speaking could be associated
with the Greek philosopher Plato who believed rhetoric to obscure the truth.
Plato understood Rhetoric to be nothing but mere “flattery”, repeating only
what the audience desires to hear. Great philosophers and thinkers such as
Francis Bacon and Thomas Sprat have had diverse definitions for the word over
the years.
Locke
Let me preface this by saying, I completely understand and mostly agree with Locke's explanation of language, words, sensations and all of it. But I think an interesting thought in regards to it is how language and sensations are so immensely personal to us and yet they are also the thing that connects us the most to one another.
Everyone has the same identified emotions and words that correlate, i.e., happy, sad, scared, angry. But those words and feelings all come with a different mental image, or instance or feeling depending on the person. For example, there are people who identify themselves sexually as liking physical pain whereas that's taboo in our society and we think of it as unconventional, weird or perhaps a little scary. And coming from someone who doesn't identify themselves as such, I get the mental picture of blood, bruises, people screaming. But to those that do, that idea would bring about feelings of sensualness, excitement, enticement. And the mental picture might come across as something of people making love, or smiling faces. It's the same act but because of the words we use to arbitrarily use to define those varying emotions they come across societally very different.
Call a Locke-smith..
Although somewhat longwinded, I love the root of Locke's argument in this reading: Language is ambiguous. We should language with the knowledge that it is a system based on empty connections. Locke argues that through societal consensus, words gain and retain meaning, that everything we can name is a product of human decision. If "complex ideas are formed by the connections among simple ideas," and simple ideas are only the products of overlapping consensus, what then is our system on communication based upon? (Locke, 815).
Locke and Sound
While the majority of Locke's essay deals with the problem of actually defining what constitutes words and language, I really would like to focus on something Locke mentions only briefly, sound. Sound is crucial to creating words, language, and ultimately communication. Although, it would be interesting to see what Locke would have to say about how sign language and body language permit communication. However, Locke says that "sounds have no natural connection with our ideas" (Locke 817). Yet, he also contradicts this when he says that sounds are usually learned first when learning to speak as a child. (Locke 819) Only when you first learn the pronunciation of words can you then begin to understand the complex ideas words stand for. So, are words just simply meanings of different sounds? How about adjusting sound or volume to create different tones and pitches. Would things like sarcasm even exist without tone? Or what about emotions? The volume and sound of one's voice and words certainly dictate someone's emotion and how they communicate with others.
Just another Rhetoric device
Ecoporn.
What a graphic name for a concept that isn't as graphic as we would like to think it is. Or is it?
This past week, I keep coming back to thinking about Ecoporn and what Welling was trying to get at. He mentions that Mander states, "Ecopornography is like 'real' pornography, because it masks sordid agendas with illusions of beauty and perfection." (pg.54) Wellings believed that it was an "unfruitful metaphor" for the term Ecoporn.
So what is Ecoporn? Is it the degradation of nature in our society, just like human pornography is? Or is it something completely different? The academic definition of pornography is this: the depiction of acts in a sensational manner so as to arouse a quick intense emotional reaction. (Merriam Webster)
What a graphic name for a concept that isn't as graphic as we would like to think it is. Or is it?
This past week, I keep coming back to thinking about Ecoporn and what Welling was trying to get at. He mentions that Mander states, "Ecopornography is like 'real' pornography, because it masks sordid agendas with illusions of beauty and perfection." (pg.54) Wellings believed that it was an "unfruitful metaphor" for the term Ecoporn.
So what is Ecoporn? Is it the degradation of nature in our society, just like human pornography is? Or is it something completely different? The academic definition of pornography is this: the depiction of acts in a sensational manner so as to arouse a quick intense emotional reaction. (Merriam Webster)